top of page

I won a Book Award. Kind Of.

  • jeremynoad
  • 4 days ago
  • 4 min read

My first novel, Fractured Echoes, won an award. Kind of.


That is how I have learnt to say it, because there is a fine line between sharing good news and sounding like the sort of person who starts a sentence with “as an award-winning author” while reaching for a velvet smoking jacket.


To be precise, Fractured Echoes was named a finalist in the 2026 Next Generation Indie Book Awards. It was in the top ten for Best Debut Novel. I received a certificate, a silver medal, and a level of quiet personal satisfaction that was not entirely in keeping with my normal attempts to appear balanced and mature.


I was very pleased. I did not walk around the house wearing the medal. Not much, anyway. But I did keep looking at it. I looked at the certificate as well. More than once. I may also have spent some time thinking about whether it should be framed and placed somewhere visible, such as the entrance hall, where guests could notice it without me having to say, “Have you seen my certificate?”


This is, of course, a humble brag. There is no point pretending otherwise. But I think there is also a useful lesson in it, because the whole thing made me think about silver medals in a way I did not expect.


Last year, an esteemed business professor and I wrote an academic article on why silver medals are, in emotional terms, the worst medals. The argument was based on research into counterfactual thinking. Gold is best, of course. Nobody needs a journal article for that. But bronze often feels better than silver because bronze says, “I could have got nothing, but I got a medal.” Silver says, “I nearly got gold.”


In other words, bronze compares down. Silver compares up. That was the logic. It made sense. The research supported it. The article was serious, structured, and probably contained far fewer thoughts about where to hang certificates.


Then I received a silver medal for my novel and became a walking challenge to my own argument. Because I was not sitting there thinking, “How disappointing, I could have won.” I was thinking, “I wrote a book, sent it into the world, and someone who had no obligation to be kind decided it belonged in the final group.” That felt good. It still feels good.


This is the part where personal experience does what it often does. It walks into the room, looks at rational analysis, and says, “Yes, very interesting. Anyway, I’m happy.”


Part of the reason, I think, is that publishing your first novel is strange. You spend months, sometimes years, writing something in private. You doubt it. You edit it. You read it too many times. You stop seeing the words properly. Then, one day, it becomes a real book and people you do not know can read it, judge it, ignore it, enjoy it, misunderstand it, or close it after three pages and never mention it again.


That is quite a lot to hand over to the world. So when any sort of recognition comes back, it matters. Not because it proves the book is perfect. It does not. Not because it turns you into a literary giant. It really does not. But because it gives you a small, solid piece of evidence that the work reached someone. And for a first novel, that means something.

There are some things in life that can only happen once. You can only publish your first novel once. You can only get your first reader once. Your first review, your first sale, your first person telling you they stayed up late to finish the book. After that, you may get better, broader, more serious, more professional. But you do not get another first.

That is why the medal mattered to me. It was not really about silver. It was not even only about the award. It was about marking the moment. I had written a novel. I had finished it. I had published it. It had gone further than I expected. And someone, somewhere, had sent me a medal for it. I am not made of stone. Also, it is quite a nice medal.

Would I recommend entering book awards? Yes, with a little care and a grip on your own expectations. Do not enter every award you see. Check who runs it, what the categories are, what previous winners look like, what the fee is, and whether the award has any value for your kind of book. But if the award is credible and the category fits, I think it is worth considering.


For a new author, an award entry is not only about winning. It gives the book another chance to be read outside your own circle. It gives you a date in the calendar. It gives you something to work towards after launch, when the first rush has passed and you are wondering what to do next. And if the book is shortlisted, placed, or recognised in any way, it gives you something real to use in your author bio, website, book page, press note, and the slightly awkward posts where you try to tell people good news without sounding unbearable.


It also does something more personal. It tells you that the book has left your desk and entered the world. Someone has read it. Someone has compared it with other books. Someone has decided it belongs in the conversation. For a first novel, that is not a small thing.


The lesson, if there is one, is that research can tell us a lot about how people tend to respond. It can show patterns. It can explain why silver can sting when someone has spent years chasing gold. But context matters. For a first-time novelist, a silver medal may not feel like nearly winning. It may feel like being seen.


That does not make the research wrong. It just reminds me that people are not case studies when they are living the moment themselves. We are inconsistent. We are emotional. We can write an article saying silver medals are psychologically difficult, then receive one and immediately start pricing frames.


I am not proud of this. Actually, I am slightly proud of it. So yes, Fractured Echoes won an award. Kind of. And I am going to enjoy it, while pretending I have not already thought about where the certificate might look best.

Comments


bottom of page